Paul Nicholls

Paul Nicholls has been THE jumps trainer of the last 10 years. The Ditcheat handler has looked after superstars such as Kauto Star, Denman, Big Bucks and Master Minded, and has won countless Grade One contests with the aforementioned runners, as well as with a number of other high class recruits.

In this article we take a look at how Nicholls’ runners perform under a variety of conditions.

Hurdlers

Juvenile, Novice and Maiden Hurdlers

Nicholls’ horses making their debut over timber who have had previous racecourse experience, be it in bumpers or on the flat are 48/225 (21.33%) for a loss of £-49.55, giving an A/E of 0.88.

Interestingly, his runners who have not seen the track in any shape or form before, do better; 54/189 (28.57%) for £9.62 LSP, giving an A/E of 1.03.

Handicap Hurdlers by Month

Month	Runners	Winners	Win S/R	P/L to SP	A/E
January	88	18	20.45%	£5.35	1.11
February	121	23	19.01%	-£11.03	1.02
March	160	22	13.75%	£8.38	1.20
April	179	24	13.41%	-£48.17	0.92
May	44	9	20.45%	£0.95	1.26
June	27	5	18.52%	£0.88	1.03
July	12	1	8.33%	-£8.50	0.45
August	12	2	16.67%	£6.50	1.31
September	5	0	0%	-£5.00	0
October	91	15	16.48%	-£20.24	0.88
November	159	23	14.47%	-£28.97	0.96
December	105	19	18.10%	-£11.17	0.99

Nicholls does well at a number of courses, including top courses such as Sandown and Cheltenham. He doesn’t really do poorly anywhere apart from Aintree, where his record is just 1/53.

A large portion of those handicap hurdlers are going to Aintree on the back of running at Cheltenham, and many have struggled after having hard races at Prestbury Park.

Handicap Hurdlers by Course

Course	Runners	Winners	Win S/R	P/L to SP	A/E
Ffos Las	6	3	50%	9.75	2.96
Sandown	73	14	19.18%	26.62	1.38
Cheltenham	192	26	13.54%	15.58	1.22
Taunton	84	21	25%	-1.73	1.19
Stratford	10	1	10%	-7.63	0.59
Chepstow	75	7	9.33%	-38.08	0.54
Fontwell	11	1	9.09%	-8	0.52
Aintree	53	1	1.89%	-47.5	0.18

Chasers

Novice Chasers by Month

Month	Runners	Winners	Win S/R	P/L to SP	A/E
January	83	22	26.51%	-£31.55	0.84
February	89	31	34.83%	-£10.84	0.95
March	90	20	22.22%	-£39.71	0.86
April	124	36	29.03%	-£27.18	0.95
May	32	12	37.50%	-£4.76	0.91
June	22	9	40.91%	-£1.62	1.07
July	11	3	27.27%	£0.50	0.91
August	18	7	38.89%	-£6.35	1.27
September	12	3	25%	-£5.91	0.66
October	69	33	47.83%	£18.27	1.29
November	139	50	35.97%	-£10.62	1.08
December	127	43	33.86%	£1.78	1.13

Nicholls’ runners at the start of the jumps season do very well in novice chases (October-December); 126/335 (37.61%) for £9.42 LSP, giving an A/E of 1.15. Once the year turns, they become much less profitable (January-March); 73/262 (27.86%) for a loss of £-82.10, giving an A/E of 0.89.

Handicap Chasers by Month

Month	Runners	Winners	Win S/R	P/L to SP	A/E
January	143	19	13.29%	-£9.25	0.91
February	117	15	12.82%	-£44.65	0.82
March	172	20	11.63%	-£32.75	0.92
April	245	24	9.80%	-£78.76	0.82
May	60	10	16.67%	-£9.51	0.74
June	32	8	25%	-£1.21	1.28
July	35	2	5.71%	£19.63	0.42
August	31	3	9.68%	-£20.00	0.73
Septbember	15	2	13.33%	-£0.17	0.74
October	118	17	14.41%	£52.45	0.75
November	252	43	17.06%	-£10.18	1.15
December	214	33	15.42%	£20.32	1.01

It appears that Nicholls handicap returners have a modest record in September and October when the jumps season gets underway. They improve significantly in November and December, producing higher strike rate and A/E’s over 1.0.

After the turn of the year however, his handicap chasers tend to perform lower than market expectations. Overall, they don’t provide great value.

Handicap Chasers by Course

Course	Runners	Winners	Win S/R	P/L to SP	A/E
Wetherby	8	4	50%	£7.90	2.16
Newbury	131	31	23.66%	£40.18	1.53
Kempton	52	10	19.23%	£4.50	1.34
Wincanton	136	29	21.32%	£16.63	1.10
Ayr	36	2	5.56%	-£25.67	0.43
Exeter	40	3	7.50%	-£26.50	0.40
Fontwell	22	1	4.55%	-£17.50	0.24
Market Rasen	19	0	0%	-£19.00	0

Paul Nicholls’ record at Newbury with his chasers is very impressive, especially considering that the Berkshire venue is one of the premier jumps courses and attracts a high calibre of opposition. He clearly doesn’t send his good ones to Market Rasen.

Last Time Out Winners

When Nicholls has a last time out winner in a handicap chase, their success really depends upon the number of days off the track, and market position.

Horses who are returning within 21 days are:

20/75 (26.67%) for a loss of £-9.64, giving an A/E of 1.14

Breaking that down further, if the horses are fancied in the market (1st or 2nd favourite), they are 20/52 (38.46%) for £13.36 LSP, producing an A/E of 1.32. Third favourite or lower in the betting, and they are 0/23.

Nicholls last time out winners off for more than 3 weeks have a poor record; 16/160 (10%) for loss of £-82.30, giving an A/E of 0.62. When outside the first two in the market, they are just 1/71 (1.41%) for a loss of £-60, for an A/E of 0.17.

National Hunt Flat

Bumper Debutants by Month

Month	Runners	Winners	Win S/R	P/L to SP	A/E
January	21	2	9.52%	-£11.00	0.55
February	25	4	16%	-£12.14	0.78
March	17	3	17.65%	-£1.75	0.97
April	35	11	31.43%	-£1.72	1.44
May	19	7	36.84%	-£7.50	1.28
June	6	1	16.67%	-£2.25	0.69
July	1	0	0%	-£1.00	0
August	1	1	100%	£3.50	4.70
September	1	0	0%	-£1.00	0
October	23	3	13.04%	-£14.50	0.54
November	31	7	22.58%	-£5.08	1.04
December	23	4	17.39%	-£9.63	0.70

Nicholls underperforms from December to March, but then does particularly well in April and May. His record towards the end of the jumps season with his bumper debutants is 18/54 (33.33%) for £5.78 LSP, giving an A/E of 1.38. He doesn’t have many runners through the summer.

NHF Debutants by Course

Course	Runners	Winners	Win S/R	P/L to SP	A/E
Stratford	6	3	50%	£12.25	2.40
Newton Abbot	10	5	50%	£9.75	1.88
Taunton	15	5	33.33%	£4.00	1.74
Chepstow	23	9	39.13%	£2.28	1.33
Worcester	36	2	5.56%	-£7.50	0.29
Newbury	40	3	7.50%	-£9.00	0
Ludlow	22	1	4.55%	-£7.00	0
Kempton	19	0	0%	-£10.00	0

Day of the Week

Commentators and pundits alike always make reference to the fact that Nicholls is the king of Saturdays. Is this backed up by the stats?

Hurdlers and Chasers by Day

Day	Runners	Winners	Win S/R	P/L to SP	A/E
Friday	829	180	21.71%	-£139.79	0.96
Monday	295	72	24.41%	-£66.10	0.86
Saturday	1,961	422	21.52%	-£168.21	1.04
Sunday	565	145	25.66%	-£88.77	0.93
Thursday	770	185	24.03%	-£138.69	1.00
Tuesday	479	128	26.72%	-£85.75	0.94
Wednesday	464	110	23.71%	-£44.53	0.99

In a word, yes. Nicholls has comfortably the most number of runners on Saturday’s and although his strike rate is lowest (this can be expected as racing is more competitive on Saturday), the A/E produced by his runners is comfortably the highest.

He really does prime his runners for the big races on racings biggest day of the week.

Review

Nicholls juvenile, novice and maiden hurdlers do best on debut when they have not been to the racetrack before (in a flat or bumper contest).
His handicap hurdlers do best in the first 6 months of the year.
Nicholls handicap hurdlers should be respected at Sandown and Cheltenham. He does poorly at Aintree.
He has a great record in novice chases in October-December. His runners’ performances tail off after that.
November and December are the time to catch Nicholls handicap chasers. They don’t have a great record throughout most of the rest of the year however.
He does do especially well with handicap chasers at Newbury, but hasn’t had a winner at Market Rasen.
The performance of handicap chasers who won last time out depends on how long they are off the track, and their market position. Those runners returning within 3 weeks who are 1st or 2nd favourite have a great record. If they are not fancied, they do very poorly and runners off for more than 3 weeks have a moderate record.
Nicholls is prolific with bumper debutants in April and May.
The Ditcheat handler targets the big races on Saturday, and produces the best value with his runners on racing’s biggest day of the week.